Gutter care guide
Leaking Gutter Joint: Reseal, Repair or Replace?
A joint that drips is usually a failed seal, and resealing it is a small job. A gutter that is cracked, rusted through, or brittle and sagging across several joints is a replacement. The age of the gutter and the cost of repeated repairs usually decide which way to go, so look at the whole run rather than one joint.
Plastic gutters
Modern uPVC gutters use clip-in joints with a rubber seal that dries and loosens with time and sun. Often the seal can be refreshed or a union replaced. Old, brittle plastic that cracks as it is touched is past its life and is better replaced.
Cast iron gutters
Cast iron joints are bolted and sealed with a mastic or putty that eventually fails. Resealing is a standard job. If the metal around the joint is flaking, thin or cracked, the joint has done its time.
Deciding
One or two weeping joints on an otherwise sound gutter: reseal. Many joints failing, cracked sections, or a run that has lost fall: replace the run. Whichever it is, clear the gutter first so the seal can be checked and the water runs clear.
If the fascia behind is soft, fix that before anything else.
Common questions
Is silicone enough to seal a gutter joint?
Short term, perhaps. A proper gutter sealant or new union gives a longer fix. Poor sealing over dirt will fail again.
How long do gutters last?
Cast iron can run for many decades with care. Plastic usually lasts for decades too, but UV and age make it brittle.